Candy Bar Cake Challenge

Share It!

Y’all remember the Candy Bar Cake Challenge?

You saw my hideous concoction…

Candy Bar Cake Challenge

…then I challenged you to send me your not so hideous creation.

Two brave readers have accepted my throw-down and submitted their pics. While no one has dared to make the cake in it’s three-layer glory, you guys did make some tasty lookin’ sheet cakes.

First up is Megan’s interpretation: We took the liberty of using dark chocolate milky ways and putting caramel on top and letting it soak in.

Oh, momma!

Candy Bar Cake Challenge

image source: megan

Yes, please.

Next up is Jonna’s interpretation: Does this look like an ugly cake to you?!

Candy Bar Cake Challenge

image source: jonna

Um, NO!  This looks like something I should have in mah belly…RIGHT NOW!

Can I get an AMEN!, Rudy?

Candy Bar Cake Challenge

image source: jonna

As we all know, the universal sign for WANT! is a tongue poised to lick some frosting.  I feel ya, brother.

Anyone else wanna try their hand at this cake?  Anyone brave enough to try it in three-layer form?

Send me your pics!

Thank you, Megan and Jonna for joining the fun!


UPDATE: Laura joined in the fun with her version, a three-layer doozie:

Candy Bar Cake Challenge

image source: laura

Y’all just keep blowing me away!


Share It!


  1. Did not know there was such a thing as an ugly cake, I love cake, especially when made with Milky Way. (mmm ooooh, and the dark chocolate ones!) Both are lovely, Good job Megan and Jonna! Not making THAT cake THIS week OMT…I hear Manhattan calling me tho, wish me lucK!

  2. Sande Sivani says

    Cake can be beautiful or “ugly” in my opinion as long as it tastes fabulous. Both of the entries in your challenge look very tasty. We would like to invite you to party with us at 5:00 on Thursday evenings at The Blog Strut Peacock Style Link Party to promote your challenge. Come on over!!

  3. Hi!
    I’m stopping by from Oh What a HAPPY DAY link party today.
    The very idea of a Candy Bar Cake Challenge has my mouth watering, and I too would have my tongue hanging out of my mouth! 🙂
    Happy Wednesday,
    – Ang

  4. I don’t care how it looks… has candy in it!!! Cute post!

  5. Looks amazing! I would love for you to share and link up at my weekly TGIF Link Party if you haven’t already this week. Your favorite posts, most popular, recent or new! The party is open every Thursday night and closes Tuesday’s at midnight. Followed by (Not SO) Wordless Wednesday!
    I would be honored if you join us and follow to stay connected Have a wonderful week!
    Hugs, Cathy

  6. Carrie @ My Favorite Finds says

    Yum! All these cakes look great! Thanks for sharing at Pinworthy Projects.

  7. I’ll take one of each 🙂 Thanks for sharing with us this week at Monday Funday!

    Take care,


Leave a Reply to Cathy Cancel reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.